Engaging students in extracurricular activities is not necessarily an easy task as students’ time is normally fully booked with academic activities, work, sports etc. Studies also show that extracurricular activities first and foremost attract students who have the time and energy to consider how extracurricular activities can benefit their learning, their CVs, and future careers. In addition to this, there are a few additional challenges attached to the offering of interdisciplinary extracurriculars. Often interdisciplinary extracurriculars are open to students from a broad variety of programs. Thus, the thematic frame of the activity must necessarily be broad and open, inviting students to define a more precise issue or problem within the frame. A caveat here is that much of the available time risks being consumed by discussions on narrowing down a topic or focus, leaving students with the experience that they need more time, and that the academic rewards of participating in the event are limited. Furthermore, the broader the theme, the more difficult it might also be for students to relate the outcomes of the activity to the academic profile of their program. A source of motivation for students, then, is the experience of relevance of an activity to their own academic profile. In addition, getting to use one’s competences in the solution of a common problem and the social aspect of spending time together with students from other programs also strengthen students’ interests in participating in interdisciplinary curriculars. For teachers organizing interdisciplinary extracurriculars, it may be a challenge to find the balance between attracting a heterogeneous student group (which students seem to appreciate) and creating an academically rewarding experience for everyone (which is also expected by students).